Eurograd message

Message posted on 18/01/2023

STS Italia Conf 2023 - CfP "Technologies of Discontinuation"

Dear colleagues, (apologies for cross-posting)

We are pleased to invite you to submit abstract proposals to our panel "Technologies of Discontinuation. Towards Transformative Innovation Policies" (Panel n. 50 - panel description below) at the 9th STS Italia Conference “Interesting Worlds to come. Science & Technology Studies facing more-than-human challenges”, University of Bologna, Italy, 28-30 June 2023.

Follow this link: and submit a title, and a short abstract of less than 300 words by January 22nd, 2023. If you have any questions please send me an email.

Best wishes,

Stefan Kuhlmann (and Peter Stegmaier; Pierre-Benoit Joly) Professor emeritus of Science, Technology and Society (STS) | Science, Technology, & Policy Studies (STəPS) | University of Twente, Netherlands | |

Panel 40

“Technologies of Discontinuation. Towards Transformative Innovation Policies”

Organisers: Stefan Kuhlmann, University of Twente, Netherlands,; Peter Stegmaier, University of Twente, Netherlands,; Pierre-Benoît Joly, INRA, France,

Getting rid of incumbent socio-technical systems has become a pressing issue for governments as well as economic and societal actors, certainly since the 2020s. Climate change and accelerating global environmental devastation ask for fast abolition of unsustainable ways of energy production and consumption, of agriculture and food production, or of transportation (IPCC 2022). On top of this, since the last turn of century, the global economic and security architecture is dramatically changing in a way that suggests national governments to reduce dependence on international provision with natural resources (such as fossil fuels) and foreign technologies: countries feel the need to abandon vulnerable technological infrastructures and replace them by innovative, more sustainable “local” alternatives (e.g., Edler et al. 2021). So radical change is required. But how to do this?

In science, technology and innovation studies (STIS) little was known about how incumbent socio-technical regimes cease to exist when there are governance efforts to discontinue them in active ways. For a few years now, however, there has been an increase in research and publications that address this question or at least deal with general questions of the destabilisation of sociotechnical regimes (Turnheim 2012; Turnheim and Geels 2012, 2013; Stegmaier et. al. 2014; Koretsky et al. 2023; Goulet and Vinck 2023).

After a series of case studies carried out by the session organisers and by a growing international group of researchers, it is possible to sketch basic patterns and concrete case examples of actively governing the discontinuation of sociotechnical regimes in different countries and on different (organisational, state and supra-state) levels. Cases include the ban on the insecticide DDT in France, UK, and the USA, the phase-out of the incandescent light bulb in the EU, and the exit from nuclear energy in Germany compared with its almost-phase-out in UK.

There is evidence that the discontinuation of a sociotechnical regime and its governance becomes possible when a misalignment of problem, policy, and political streams opens up a ‘window of opportunity’. Various discontinuation pathways can be identified, including an Ending Pathway (‘phase-out’ and ‘ban’, incremental and abrupt misalignment and ultimately discontinuation of a trajectory), a Weakening Pathway (control, restriction, reduction), a Life-cycle Pathway (what is discontinued, gets replaced or disappears), and a Continuity Pathway (when discontinuation governance fails).

Contributions to the session/track include (tbc, with working titles):

  • Peter Stegmaier: Pathways to discontinuation governance – Incandescent Light Bulb phase-out
  • Pierre-Benoît Joly: Continuous discontinuation - DDT ban as a trigger for incremental change in the pesticides sociotechnical regime
  • Phil Johnstone & Andy Stirling: Understanding (dis)continuity in German and UK nuclear power policy (tbc)
  • Stefan Kuhlmann & Peter Stegmaier: Discontinuation as key element of transformative innovation policy - strategic options
  • Other paper submissions …


EASST's Eurograd mailing list Eurograd (at) Unsubscribe or edit subscription options:

Meet us via

Report abuses of this list to

view as plain text
Follow by Email